• Two people sit in front of a projection and a flip chart easel. On a table, in front of them, there is an overhead projector and several sheets of paper and other printed material.

    cas01a.jpg

    Kirila Cvetkovska (left) and Megan Hoetger (right). Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

  • Two people sit facing the same direction. Behind them, there is wall projection of a red block with the words

    cas01b.jpg

    Kerem Ozan Bayraktar (left) and Özge Açıkkol (right). Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

  • Three people are next to a table. Two are sitting and one is standing up. On the table, there are sheets of paper with handwritten notes and an overhead projector.

    cas01c.jpg

    Özge Açıkkol (center) and Kirila Cvetkovska (right). Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

  • A person stands in front of a projection of a black-and-white diagram.

    cas02a.jpg

    Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

  • A white sheet of paper with notes, handwritten in different colours, has been stuck to the wall with two thin strips of black tape.

    cas02b.jpg

    Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

  • A person is leaning over an overhead projector. They are making notes on the sheet on the projector's stage. The image is being projected behind them. Next to the projection, a white sheet of paper with notes, handwritten in different colours, has been stuck to the wall with two thin strips of black tape.

    cas02c.jpg

    İlyas Odman. Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

  • At the end of a long table, on top of which there are several sheets of paper, a person is leaning over an overhead projector. They are making notes on the sheet on the projector's stage. Next to them, someone stands in front of a flip chart easel.

    cas02d.jpg

    Kirila Cvetkovska (left) and Marina Papazyan (right). Zone Collective (Kirila Cvetkovska and Megan Hoetger), Collective Annotation Session — Istanbul Gathering III, November 2022. 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme, organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.

Since the group’s start, Zone Collective has been developing a method of collective annotation rooted in workshopping as a primary site of knowledge production. In Fall 2021, they began to share their note-taking process with the public in the Drawing the Archive performance-lectures, and have since continued to experiment with the gesture of ‘opening up,’ arriving at the Collective Annotation Session workshop form. Beginning from the group’s archive of collective annotations on Yugoslav media histories, these sessions move out to engage with a selection of texts and materials specific to the locale of the gathering. Over a few hours, the materials are presented via overhead projector for group reading and discussion during which Zone Collective notates the collective conversation with diagrams and drawings. These notations then become a point of departure for participants to interact with the overhead projection where they are invited to map out the different frameworks of contingency through which they experience and understand cultural preservation and policy in their context(s).

For the Istanbul Gathering III (November 2022) participants engaged with a selection of texts on cultural policy related specifically to the Beyoğlu Culture Road Festival that was currently unfolding in the city. Participants in the session ranged from prominent local cultural critics, artists and architects, to international biennial visitors passing through.

Zone Collective is a collaborative research platform established in 2016 by independent cultural practitioner Kirila Cvetkovska and historian-curator Megan Hoetger as a space to intercede into historiographic conventions for understanding cultural production in geopolitical sites marked by their grey zone ‘border status(es).’

The Hauntologists Istanbul Gathering - III⁠(opens in a new tab) was convened in November 2022 within the frame of the 17th Istanbul Biennial Public and Learning Programme. The gathering was organized by Zeyno Pekünlü.